I tried going windshieldless on my '07 for a few rides on someone's suggestion that it reduces turbulence. I found that to be true - very smooth, but the wind blast was too much. It made my neck and shoulders sore. From this thread and my own experience, I think that unless you have a really big windshield, turbulence and wind blast are a zero sum game. I finally went with the CalSci +9.5" (9.5" taller than stock). With this large of a shield, you get to avoid both wind blast and turbulence. The zero sum part of that equation is that your bike looks dorky, but I've never much cared what anyone thought my bike looked like anyway. I feel the turbulent air right at the top of my helmet (I'm 6'1"), so it makes noise, but doesn't push me around. There's another version of the CalSci that is 1.5" taller, and that would probably be like riding inside a cage. I also noticed that when I started using the CalSci that different vents on the full helmet had a different impact on wind noise than before. I messed around with those till I found the best setting. Having the mouth vent open created much more noise.
According to the CalSci website that has a couple of screens on theory of aerodynamics of windshields, the holes in the bottom of the shield reduce low pressure behind it, which reduces turbulence. Another interesting thing it points out is that turbulence is reduced when the shape of the shield is smooth. The Puig DB (which I have and found to be only marginally better than the stock) has two creases in, which seem like they would be efficient little turbulence factories.