I am looking to replace my stock seat with something more comfortable. I am looking at the Corbin gunfighter and maybe something from Top Saddlery. Any thoughts or opinions?
Justin, I have the Corbin Gunfighter on my FZ and a Bill Mayer saddle on my BMW (
Custom Motorcycle Seats-Bill Mayer Saddles>). This is the 3rd Bill Mayer seat I've had, and have loved every one of them, easily put 1000-1600 mile days on it with no problem at all.
Rocky at Bill Mayer Saddles is the brother of Rick Mayer. The general consensus among my friends in the LD community is that, between the two, Bill Mayer saddles are higher quality and built from the seat pan up, which is not true of the Rick Mayer saddle. Both of these saddle makers - and Russell Daylong, which is usually only preferred by "big" guys because of the "wings" with springs in them for lateral support for a large guy's 'cheeks' that hang off the seat - are custom seats, made to your height/weight/riding style and based on photos of you sitting on the bike. The Mayer seats are just at the top end of your stated price range.
The Corbin Gunfighter isn't bad; I've put 700 mile days on it, but am ready to get off after about 500 miles. It does look great on the bike and I don't have a problem with the fact that it puts me about 1" further forward than stock seat.
I tried the Yamaha Comfort Gel seat, but found it hard and uncomfortable; stock seat was better than this supposed "comfort" seat.
+10 on wearing LD Comfort undershorts, worn as underwear. Seams and leg opening elastic on regular underwear will grind into your backside, as will denim, and these discomforts are often what contributes to sore butt after a couple hundred miles. They're spendy, but oh so worth it! Wear like iron, take two pair on trips and rinse them out at night, they're dry within a couple of hours.