Back to this... While my chain has been relatively quiet since this adjustment, I've been noticing more things that made me think the chain was actually a bit too loose. It's hard to describe what I noticed, but I imagine y'all know what I'm talking about.
Anyway, I checked it over the weekend, and I had 2.5 inches of slack. I adjusted it down to 2 inches of slack (right in the middle of the range), aligned everything, and tightened it down. Checked the alignment (with a chain laser), and it was slightly off. Started over. Tightened it down. Slightly off. I repeated this at least a half dozen times, each time trying to guess how much it should be off in the other direction, *before* tightening, so that it would be aligned after tightening. Each time, I did what y'all suggested (pushed on the wheel with my knee while tightening the axle nut). Finally got it to 2 inches of slack, and aligned, after tightening.
[ Does anybody else have this problem with chain alignment, before/after tightening the axle nut? ]
Today, I rode it to work and back. The chain whine was back this morning, and was back with a vengeance this afternoon. When I got home, I checked it again and it was at 1.5 inches of slack! I can't fathom how this happened... I had the axle nut cinched to 87 foot pounds. I imagine my torque wrench could be off, and that the nut was loose enough that the wheel could slip backward while riding. That seems kind of far fetched, though... I loosened up the axle nut again, got it back to 2 inches of slack, tightened it, and lost the alignment again. Repeat. Finally got it to be happy, at 2 inches of slack. Went for a ride, and the whine is definitely there. This time, I set my torque wrench a few foot pounds higher, in case it's at the root of my tightens-while-riding problem.
Bottom line: this is driving me nuts.
Since I've got 2 inches of slack, am I apt to be hurting anything? Like, if I'm right in the range, it seems like the chain and the bike should be fine, noise notwithstanding. What I'm worried about is damaging the chain or the rear bearings or something like that... But again, the chain tension seems to be right in the middle of the range. I know that lots of people talk about tensioning to the loose end of the range, but if I'm dead center, should I be worried?
How expensive is the S2 swing arm that y'all talk about, that makes these problems go away?
